A U S T R A L I A N   G O U R M E T   P A G E S

 

 
Pinot Challenge 2004

 

The Judges:

 

John Atwill

Roberta Muir

Tim Pak Poy

Sharon Wild

Huon Hooke

Tom Neal Tacker

Jon Osbeiston

John Cunnington

Matthew Evans

Christopher Morrison

Franz Scheurer (no vote)

Dr. Max Lake

 

The Wines:

No

Wine

Vintage

1

Providence Miguet Reserve

2002

2

Holm Oak Vineyards

2002

3

Carlei Estate

2000

4

Hurley Vineyard

2001

5

Elgee Park Baillieu Myer Family Reserve

2001

6

Di Stasio Coldstream

2001

7

Ashton Hills

2002

8

Penfolds Cellar Reserve

2001

9

Labyrinth Viggers Vineyard

2002

10

Giaconda

2001

11

Domaine A Reserve du Patron

2000

12

Curly Flat

2000

 

The Scores

Without Food

 

Judges

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

John Atwill

8

5

11

4

10

12

7

6

1

2

9

3

John Cunnington

8

11

1

5

4

12

9

6

7

10

2

3

Matthew Evans

7

10

11

5

8

9

12

1

3

2

6

4

Huon Hooke

11

5

7

8

9

12

4

10

1

2

6

3

Dr. Max Lake

12

9

11

3

10

8

7

2

6

4

1

5

Christopher Morrison

9

7

2

8

11

12

3

1

10

6

4

5

Roberta Muir

4

2

1

3

11

10

7

8

5

12

9

6

Jon Osbeiston

7

3

4

6

10

9

8

12

1

11

2

5

Tim Pak Poy

8

5

2

1

6

12

10

9

11

3

7

4

Franz Scheurer (no vote)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tom N. Tacker

11

5

1

2

9

12

6

10

8

3

4

7

Sharon Wild

6

9

4

7

10

12

1

5

3

2

8

11

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

 

TOTAL

91

71

55

52

98

120

74

70

56

57

58

56

 

With Food:

 

Judges

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

John Atwill

9

11

7

4

10

12

6

5

1

2

8

3

John Cunnington

8

11

1

4

5

12

10

7

6

9

3

2

Matthew Evans

9

8

7

11

6

10

12

1

3

5

4

2

Huon Hooke

9

6

3

12

8

11

4

10

1

2

7

5

Dr. Max Lake

12

9

11

1

10

8

7

2

6

4

3

5

Christopher Morrison

6

12

7

9

4

11

8

3

10

2

1

5

Roberta Muir

1

9

8

2

10

4

6

3

11

7

12

5

Jon Osbeiston

6

7

4

5

10

9

8

12

1

11

3

2

Tim Pak Poy

5

8

3

1

6

12

7

4

9

11

2

10

Franz Scheurer (no vote)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tom N. Tacker

11

7

1

3

10

12

9

8

6

4

2

5

Sharon Wild

6

10

4

7

5

12

3

9

1

2

11

8

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

TOTAL

82

98

56

59

84

113

80

64

55

59

56

52

 

 

The Winners:

 

Without Food:

Hurley Vineyard Pinot Noir, Balnarring, Mornington Peninsula, Winemaker Kevin Bell

101 Balnarring Road, Balnarring VIC 3926

Tel.: 03 5931 3000

 

With Food:

Curly Flat Pinot Noir, Macedon Ranges, Lancefield, Winemaker Phillip Moraghan

263 Collivers Road, Lancefield VIC 3435

Tel.: 03 5429 1956

 

Congratulations to the winners!